Source/Read full article here.
Patrick Ness, who has won this year’s prestigious Carnegie medal for his young adult novel Monsters of Men, used his acceptance speech to launch a scorching attack on the coalition government’s policy on libraries.
Deriding plans to staff libraries with volunteers as “a one-sentence, Big Society idea whose ramifications and consequences they haven’t even remotely considered”, Ness went on to attack the education secretary, Michael Gove, as “a man who races to the latest news about what a tragedy it is that three out of 10 children don’t own a book, yet utterly fails to see the irony of how closing libraries will affect not only the three who don’t, but the seven who do and who would like to read more and more and more.”
Ness, who described himself as a “child that libraries built”, praised the work of librarians. “Librarians open up the world,” he said. “Knowledge is useless if you don’t even know where to begin to look. How much more can you discover when someone can point you in the right direction, when someone can maybe even give you a treasure map, to places you may not have even thought you were allowed to go? This is what librarians do.”
Monsters of Men is the third instalment in Ness’s Chaos Walking series. The previous two books – The Knife of Never Letting Go and The Ask and the Answer – were shortlisted for the Carnegie in 2009 and 2010 – the first time in the prize’s history that all the books in a series have been contenders.
The trilogy has been garlanded with numerous awards, from the Guardian children’s fiction prize to the Booktrust teenage prize, while Monsters of Men was shortlisted earlier this year for the Arthur C Clarke award, only the second young adult work to have been considered for the celebrated science fiction prize.
According to Ness, the spark for the final book came from watching All Quiet on the Western Front as a boy. “I was probably 14, and I was halfway through the film before I clocked the incredible fact that it’s about German soldiers … the so-called ‘enemy’,” he has said. “The worst thing we do in war is dehumanise our enemies, because that makes them easier to kill. But they stay human, no matter how much we want them not to. Monsters of Men came from wanting to explore that terrible, terrible contradiction. Wanting to dehumanise the enemy but being unable to; it’s about the ambiguity and messiness of war.”
Ferelith Hordon, chair of the Carnegie 2011 judging panel, called Monsters of Men an “extraordinary achievement”.
“Within its pages, Patrick Ness creates a complex other world, giving himself and the reader great scope to consider big questions about life, love and how we communicate, as well as the horrors of war, and the good and evil that mankind is capable of,” she said. “It’s an enthralling read that is well nigh impossible to put down,”
To finally win the Carnegie is “just brilliant”, Ness told the Guardian. “It’s an amazing list of winners to join. And it’s even more amazing when you really respect the people – librarians – who gave it to you. Winning is great, but the shortlisting is genuinely a good thing because the shadowing scheme [in which thousands of young readers shadow the judging and review the books] is a real moral good. To get all those young readers arguing about books is exciting,” he said.
